Goods and Services Tax (GST) instituted in India, effective from July 1, 2017, represents an extensive array of indirect taxes levied at various stages, each under the purview of the Central and State Governments. Despite attempts to simplify the tax procedure, ease compliance, and free flow of business activities through GST, a critical issue is the problem of non-compliance. Noncompliance under GST means any form of default in such regulations, standards, and obligations that are laid down under the GST law. This includes things like non-filing or late filing of returns, improper reporting of purchases or sales, suppression of sales, wrongful availing of input tax credit, not registering under GST though required, and not issuing proper tax invoices.
Noncompliance arises due to various reasons like ignorance, poor systems, genuine error in procedure, or blatant fraud. Whatever may be the underlying rationale, the consequences can be grave with very heavy penalties, interest, cancellation of registration under GST, and in extreme cases, even prosecution. To keep intact the integrity of the tax system, the entire GST mechanism has been laced with provisions for identification, prevention, and redressal of such violations. Also, with the tax officials increasingly relying on digitisation and big data analytics, compliance monitoring has become quite intensive. This implies that all taxpayers, big or small, must understand their responsibilities and comply with the provisions of GST in letter and spirit. Consequently, addressing noncompliance is not merely about evading penalties; it is also crucial for sustaining trust, ensuring operational continuity, and fostering a transparent tax environment.
What is an Incorrect or Invalid Invoice?
Under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) framework, an accurate and valid tax invoice needs to be issued to the recipient to ensure compliance with the norms, eligibility of claiming ITC, and transparency in transactions. It is a legal document that a supplier submits to the recipient, containing the details of the goods or services provided and the applicable taxes. However, if the invoice is not up to the standards set by GST laws, then the GST invoice is inaccurate or invalid.
The inaccurate and invalid GST invoice not only hinders the flow of tax credit but also exposes the business to various legal as well as financial risks. Being a core part of the GST compliance, invoices require accuracy, completeness, and proper format of presentation for all kinds of registered taxpayers. Proper documentation and accurate invoice forms constitute the two most important constituents for maintaining a compliant and effective GST.
What Would Render an Invoice Erroneous or Ineffectual?
A bill could be deemed wrong or invalid under GST if it is filled with errors, omissions, or does not contain the information required by Section 31 of the CGST Act and Rule 46 of the CGST Rules, 2017. Some of the most common grounds for an invoice being marked as wrong or invalid are:
1. Faulty GSTIN: Issuing a wrong GSTIN for either the supplier or the recipient can result in rejection of the ITC and compliance issues. It has a bearing on the automatic generation of returns and matching of data on the GST portal.
2. Missing Mandatory Details: A valid GST invoice should contain:
- the name, address, GSTIN, invoice number, and date of the supplier.
- Recipient’s name, address, and GSTIN (if registered)
- HSN/SAC codes for goods/services
- Quantity and value of goods/services.
- Taxable value and rates (CGST, SGST, IGST, or UTGST)
- Tax amount charged
- Place of supply and delivery address (particularly for interstate supplies)
- The supplier or authorised representative should give a signature or digital signature.
If any of the above information is lacking or incorrect, the invoice is invalid.
3. Incorrect Tax Calculation: Miscalculation of GST rates, taxable value, or tax amount results in discrepancies, potentially leading to underpayment or overpayment of tax. This may incur penalties or interest.
4. Misclassification of Goods or Services: Utilising wrong HSN (Harmonized System of Nomenclature) or SAC (Service Accounting Code) may mean incorrect tax rates would be charged, making the invoice invalid for compliance.
5. Mismatched Place of Supply: The place of supply determines if CGST, SGST, or IGST is applicable. A mistake with this information can lead to the imposition of the incorrect type of tax, making reporting and compliance more difficult.
6. Invoice Numbers: Every invoice should carry a consecutive serial number per fiscal year. Duplicate invoice numbers or improper formats violate GST rules.
7. Improper Date of Issue: Back-dated or post-dated invoices exceeding authorised limits can trigger doubts regarding their validity and legality.
8. Invoices Issued Without Registration: If a taxable person liable to register under GST presents bills without procuring a GSTIN, the bills are invalid and the supplier is non-compliant.
Consequences of Issuing Incorrect or Invalid Invoices
Miscalculated or invalid invoices under the Goods and Services Tax (GST) system can cause far-reaching legal, financial, and reputational damage to businesses. GST is greatly reliant on proper documentation, particularly tax invoices, for tax computation, filing of returns, and availing Input Tax Credit (ITC). Therefore, any deviation from the prescribed standards of invoicing is viewed very seriously by tax authorities.
As such, it is essential that businesses validate their invoicing processes in accordance with GST law, make use of reliable billing software, and carry out periodic audits of their documents for accuracy. Strong invoice management goes beyond legal compliance; it is central to sound financial and tax regulation in the GST environment.
Below is a detailed description of the consequences involved in the issuance of incorrect or invalid invoices under GST:
1. Rejection or denial of the input tax credit (ITC)
One of the most crippling consequences of the issuance of an incorrect invoice is the loss of Input Tax Credit for the recipient. Section 16 of the CGST Act states that it is mandatory for a buyer to claim ITC only when he has a valid tax invoice. The recipient may lose ITC entitlement in case the invoice does not have key elements (e.g., GSTIN, tax value, HSN code, etc.) or inaccurate information, which adds to the effective procurement expenses and generates controversy between parties.
2. Monetary penalties and fines
Harsh punishment is levied for non-adherence under Section 122 of the Act. The penalty for issuing an incorrect or fictitious invoice without receipt of goods or services is ₹10,000 or the tax evaded amount, whichever is greater.
Errors in invoicing that result in evasion of tax or unjustified ITC can be penalised up to 100%. Up to ₹25,000 as penalty may be levied for issuing invoices in error under Section 125 (general penalty clause).
3. Short payment or unpaid interest on taxes
In case of an incorrect invoice that leads to short payment of tax, the taxpayer must pay interest on the short payment or underpayment. The rate of interest is:
- 18% per annum for the delayed payment of tax
- 24% for over-claims of ITC or incorrect invoicing, leading to a saving of tax.
It adds to the financial burden of the business.
4. Audit, investigation, and litigation risks
Issuing the wrong invoices increases the taxpayer’s likelihood of being selected for notice, audit, or investigation. Continuing discrepancies can lead to a GST audit or examination by the authorities, compelling extra documentation requisitions like:
- Suspension of registration
- Issuance of show-cause notices
- Delayed judicial proceedings
5. Cancellation of GST registration
Where false invoices are generated intentionally or systematically, the tax authorities can cancel the GST registration under Section 29 of the CGST Act. The scenario is particularly applicable for cases of fraudulent invoicing, bogus suppliers, or shell companies. After the cancellation, the company cannot make taxable supplies or issue tax invoices legally, and this affects its functioning and income directly.
6. Reputation loss and business loss
Faulty bills can disrepute a business in the eyes of customers and suppliers. Purchasers depend on accurate bills to recover ITC. If a company keeps generating incorrect bills, it can lose trust and reputation, causing:
- Loss of customers or contracts
- Litigation by purchasers demanding reimbursement for the loss of ITC
- Placement on government watchlists.
7. Discrepancy in GST returns (GSTR-1 and GSTR-3B)
Incorrect invoicing might lead to inconsistencies in data between GSTR-1 (outward supply information) and GSTR-3B (aggregate return), or between recipient and supplier returns (GSTR-2B). Incompatibilities might lead to:
- Section 61 (Return Scrutiny) compliance notices
- Rule 86A ITC Blocking
- Alerts or actions prompted by GSTN.
8. Legal action and prosecution (in extreme situations)
If wrong bills are issued with the intention of misleading the government, like issuing false ITC or evading taxes, the penalties may increase to:
- Prosecution under Section 132 of the CGST Act
- Imprisonment for a maximum period of 5 years, as per the seriousness of the offense
- Criminal liability for responsible persons, including officers and directors.
How to Avoid Mistakes When Issuing Incorrect Invoices?
By following these guidelines, businesses can significantly reduce the chances of creating wrong or invalid invoices in accordance with GST rules.
- Utilise the GST-compliant accounting software where the invoicing systems are updated with GST rules and formats.
- Include all mandatory fields and specify details such as GSTIN, invoice number, date, HSN/SAC codes, tax amount, and place of supply.
- Verify GSTINs of parties and cross check the GSTIN of buyers/suppliers using the GST portal to prevent errors.
- Use proper tax rates and HSN/SAC codes with appropriate classification and accompanying tax rate for goods or services.
- Use unique and sequential invoice numbers by maintaining a uniform numbering sequence for every financial year.
- Provide a proper place of supply, assisting in identifying whether to charge IGST or CGST/SGST.
- Train the staff periodically and educate them on GST invoice provisions and updates.
- Undertake regular invoice audits to identify errors and rectify them.
- Adopt and adhere to the approved and standard invoice forms laid down under GST law.
- Issue Invoices on Time
- Don’t backdate or delay invoices after statutory time limits.
- Match with GSTR Filings
- Verify invoice information corresponds with returns (GSTR-1, GSTR-3B) to prevent mismatches.
Conclusion
Incorrect GST invoicing can bring serious penalties, loss of input tax credits, interest liability, audits, and even cancellation of registration. It derails the process of compliance, jeopardizes business relationships, and could attract legal attention. Therefore, businesses must ensure accurate and timely billing as an essential aspect of their GST compliance. Adopting proper procedures and practices ensures the smooth conduct of business operations, proper handling of finance, and compliance with all the legal stipulations of the GST regime.
Related Services
