Transfer Pricing plays an important role in taxation and corporate compliance in international trade, particularly in multinational companies. It regulates the determination of prices in transactions between the related parties and the artificial redistribution of profits to the low-tax jurisdictions. In India, the government closely monitors transfer pricing laws at the Income Tax Department to avoid tax evasion and revenue loss.
The article presents the meaning, purpose, and key methodologies of transfer pricing in an understandable, systematic way.
What is Transfer Pricing?
Transfer Pricing is the pricing of goods, services, or intangible assets between two or more related enterprises within the same group, especially when the enterprises involved are in different countries or tax jurisdictions.
In these transactions, there can be.
- Sale or purchase of goods
- Provision of services
- Intellectual property transfer/licensing.
- Loan facilities and interest expense.
Tax authorities control such transactions under transfer pricing laws because related parties can manipulate prices to reduce total tax payments.
Legal Framework of Transfer Pricing in India
In India, Sections 92 to 92F of the Income-tax Act, 1961, containing the provisions of transfer pricing, are supplemented by the Rules of 10A to 10E of the Income-tax Rules, 1962.
These provisions apply to.
- International dealings amongst affiliate businesses.
- Defined domestic transactions that are above the prescribed levels.
India adheres to the internationally recognised arm’s-length principle, as outlined in the OECD guidelines.
What is the Arm Length Principle?
Arm Length Principle stipulates that the transactions between related parties must be priced as though they were carried out between unrelated parties under comparable situations.
The price between the group companies in simple terms should be equal to the price that would have been charged to an independent third party.
This is the underlying principle of any transfer pricing regulations and methodologies.
Purpose of Transfer Pricing
The transfer pricing regulations have several significant purposes in both taxation and corporate governance.
- Prevention of Tax Avoidance: Low-tax or no-tax jurisdictions are among the chief reasons transfer pricing is used to shift profits from high-tax to low-tax or no-tax jurisdictions.
- Assuring Equitable Tax Distribution: Transfer pricing ensures that profits are distributed equally across countries where real economic activities are undertaken and value is generated.
- Ensuring Candidness and Integrity: Cross-border transactions and voluntary compliance with tax obligations are enhanced by the availability of necessary documentation and disclosures.
- Insurance of Government Revenue: By controlling related-party transactions, transfer pricing laws protect national tax revenue and prevent base erosion.
Transfer Pricing Regulations Applicability
When the following conditions are met, then transfer pricing provisions are applicable.
- The associated enterprises are involved in a transaction.
- It is an international transaction or a given domestic transaction.
- It involves an element of transfer of income, expense or asset.
Shareholding, management control, common ownership and financial dependence may result in the existence of associated enterprises.
Transfer Pricing Methodologies
The Indian transfer pricing legislation identifies five standard procedures of setting the arm length price and one remainder procedure.
1. Comparable Uncontrolled Price (CUP) Method
CUP method involves comparing the price billed in a controlled setting to that billed in a similar uncontrolled setting.
This is deemed to be the most direct and sure in case of similar data at hand.
Commonly used for:
- Commodity transactions
- Benchmarking of loan and interest.
- Royalty payments
Its applicability is, however, limited because it is difficult to find specific comparables.
2. Resale Price Method (RPM)
Under the Resale Price Method, the resale price to an unrelated party is negotiated, resulting in an arm length price adjusted by an applicable gross margin.
This method is suitable where:
- Purchases of goods are made through related business ventures, which resell them without any value addition.
- The distributors are regular resellers.
RPM focuses on gross profit margins rather than net margins.
3. Cost Plus Method (CPM)
The Cost Plus Method involves determining the price of the arm as a combination of the supplier’s costs plus a suitable markup.
This method is commonly used for:
- Provision of services
- Contract manufacturing: arrangements.
- Intra-group support services.
The problem is in calculating the right cost base and the markup percentage.d
4. Profit Split Method (PSM)
The Profit Split Method is a method that allocates the combined profits of transactions controlled by related enterprises in proportion to each enterprise’s contribution.
This method is suitable when:
- The transactions are very integrated.
- It involves unique intangibles.
- There is value added by both parties.
PSM is commonly used in the structuring of multinational arrangements that involve common risks and assets.
5. Transactional Net Margin Method (TNMM)
TNMM measures net profit margin relative to an appropriate base, such as costs, sales, or assets.
The most frequently used approach in India is driven by the availability of similar data.
TNMM is applied in.
- Routine manufacturing
- IT and IT-enabled services
- Support services and back-office services.
The approach is more based on net margins as opposed to transaction-oriented pricing.
6. Other Method (Residual Method)
The “Other Method enables the determination of arm length price with any method that considers price charged in similar uncontrolled transactions.
This is a flexible approach that cannot be used with conventional techniques, especially in intangible valuation.
Requirements of Transfer Pricing Documentation
Covered transactions require that the taxpayer keep prescribed records of the transactions, including.
- Nature and terms of international transactions.
- Functional analysis, Asset analysis, and Risk analysis.
- Justification and reason for the choice of a transfer pricing method.
- Similar analysis and benchmarking.
Failure to comply may result in tax liabilities and modifications by tax jurisdictions.
Significance of Transfer Pricing to Businesses
In the case of multinational and cross-border businesses, the transfer pricing compliance is a mandatory activity. Appropriate transfer pricing guarantees.
- Reduced litigation risk
- Evasion of severe penalties.
- Uninterrupted audits and evaluations.
- The better corporate governance.
Credibility with tax authorities is also strengthened by well-documented transfer pricing policies.
Conclusion
Transfer Pricing is an essential part of international taxation, as it ensures that related parties in transactions are taxed at fair market value. Its main aim is to avoid profit shifting, ensure transparency and safeguard tax revenues. Understanding the arm’s-length principle and applying relevant transfer pricing approaches, a business can achieve compliance and reduce contentious issues.
The globalised economy today requires robust transfer pricing policies to ensure business sustainability and compliance with the law.
Related Service
