The Goods and Services Tax (GST) system is a self-assessment tax system, in which taxpayers are responsible for calculating and paying their own tax liability. This involves holding individuals and businesses accountable for evaluating and paying taxes on time and accurately. However, mistakes can happen whether deliberate or unintentional, resulting in incorrect tax payments.
In such instances, if the tax authorities hold that the taxpayer has failed to accurately determine their tax liability, whether owing to negligence, wrong interpretation, or intentional evasion, they possess the authority to promulgate by a “proper officer” (an officer certified by the GST law), requesting the taxpayer to explain why they should not be held accountable for the discrepancies recognized.
Provisions under Which Show Cause Notice Can be Delivered
1. Section 73 of CGST Act
Under Section 73 of the CGST Act, SCN can be delivered when tax is short-paid, unpaid, mistakenly refunded, or when Input Tax Credit (ITC) is mistakenly availed or used due to reasons apart from fraud or any deliberate misstatement or suppression of facts (bona fide or genuine mistakes). These mistakes may occur unintentionally, and the SCN provides taxpayers with an opportunity to explain and correct such errors.
2. Section 74 of CGST Act
SCN can be delivered under this provision in cases where tax evasion occurs due to willful misstatements, fraud, or suppression of facts with the aim of avoiding tax payment. This section provides the legal framework for tax officials to claim and recover taxes in instances where taxpayers intentionally engage in activities designed to evade their tax liabilities. Section 74 highlights more serious offences where there is a fraudulent motive or purposeful withholding of information.
3. Section 74A of CGST Act 2(91) of CGST Act, 2017
Instances where this section can be drawn. Short paid, tax unpaid, erroneous refund, ITC wrongly used. An interesting aspect to note here is that the notice does not specify whether it is a non-fraud or fraud case in its declaration.
4. Section 76 of CGST Act
Section 76 pertains to taxes that have been earned but remain unpaid to the government. Under the GST Acts, any amount collected as “tax” must be refunded to the government instantly, irrespective of whether the transactions were taxable.
In that case, the Proper Officer may deliver a GST SCN to the person liable for paying the amount, requiring them to justify why the specified amount was unpaid. They must also show why a penalty of a similar amount should not be levied on them under the provisions of this Section.
5. Section 129 of CGST Act
SCN under this section is issued when the relevant officer has reason to suppose that any person is moving or storing goods in violation of the provisions of the CGST Act. When such instances arise, all goods, the means to transport the goods, and other related documents may be detained and/or seized.
GST Show Cause Notice and its Parts
A ‘Show Cause’ is an official communication that is sent to a person and requires a response from them concerning a particular matter, which is usually related to misconduct or breach of rules. It is usually issued by a court, a qualified authority, or an entity, requesting the recipient to substantiate why disciplinary action should not be taken against them for occurrences such as violations, poor performance, or other wrongdoing. Ingredients of a legal show cause notice shall include Introduction of the case, Factual statement and acknowledgement of evidence, Legal framework, discussion, legal framework and facts, discussion on limitation, computation of duty and other amounts outstanding, statement of charges and power to adjudicate.
After a show-cause notice is disseminated, it shall include necessary particulars, which shall be regarded against the assessee while submitting a reply. If a show cause notice is not published with sufficient details, then the same shall not sustain or the following order passed from it. Furthermore, merely citing provisions that are breached is insufficient. Non-mentioning such factual situations will not provide the assessee a correct opportunity to respond and will ultimately infringe the principles of natural justice.
How to Respond to GST Show Cause Notices Effectively?
Replying to a GST Show Cause Notice needs a systematic and careful approach. Ensuring compliance with show cause notices in India involves several key steps to secure your interests and present your case effectively. Incomplete or hasty replies can be as harmful as no reply at all. Pursue these steps for a strong response:
Step 1: Examine the SCN Thoroughly
The initial and most crucial step is to scan the Show Cause Notice carefully from beginning to end. Don’t simply glance through it; take the time to comprehend every detail. Pay careful attention to the specific accusations being made – what precisely is the department claiming you did wrong? Recognise the precise discrepancies highlighted (e.g., mismatch between specific returns, wrong ITC claimed on specific invoices). Mark the financial duration(s) the notice relates to. Also, carefully register administrative details: the designation and name of the publishing authority, the unique SCN date and number, and, most importantly, the deadline by which your reply must be filed. Omitting this deadline can cause the ex parte orders stated earlier. Knowing the exact nature and scope of the accusations is basic to drafting a proper and effective response.
Step 2: Compile Documentation and Evidence
Once you clearly grasp the issues brought up in the SCN, the following step is to collect all appropriate documentary proof to uphold your case. This is where precise record-keeping pays off. Based on the accusations, you may need to assemble:
- Copies of proper GST returns submitted (GSTR-1, GSTR-3B, GSTR-9/9C).
- Bank statements showing payments received or made.
- Copies of e-way bills, transporter receipts, or delivery challans, if appropriate.
- Purchase invoices backing the Input Tax Credit (ITC) are asserted.
- Reconciliation statements (e.g., GSTR-1 vs GSTR-3B, ITC claimed in GSTR-3B vs GSTR-2A/2B).
- Sales invoices for the relevant period.
- Ledger accounts are linked to purchases, sales, and expenses.
- Any communication with suppliers or customers connected to the disputed transactions.
- Any appropriate contracts or agreements.
Organise this proof systematically, preferably mapping each piece of evidence to the specific point or accusation it caters to in the SCN. Having extensive and well-arranged documentation is vital for justifying your claims and refuting the department’s assertions.
Step 3: Draft a Distinct and Comprehensive Reply
After looking over the SCN and gathering evidence, it’s time to write your official response. Make your document brief, easy to understand, polite, and thorough. Answer in a sensible order, dealing with each point or claim in the SCN as they come up. For each issue:
- State the claim as it’s written in the SCN.
- Provide your exhaustive rebuttal or explanation.
- Refer expressly to the supporting documents you compiled (e.g., “As per Invoice No. ABC dated…, annexed as Annexure A”).
- Present calculations and factual data distinctly.
- If an authentic mistake occurred, it’s often better to accept it, explain the situation that caused the error (highlighting that it was unintentional), and cite any corrective actions already taken (e.g., tax paid by Form DRC-03, amended returns submitted).
- If your position depends on exclusive legal provisions, circulars, or proper case laws, state them accurately.
- Make sure you write in a polite, professional way, even if you don’t agree with what’s being said. Don’t use words that blame others or sound too emotional.
When you’re dealing with tricky tax situations involving big sums of money or complex legal stuff, it’s a good idea to get help from an expert.
Step 4: File Your Reply Before the Deadline
Drafting the ideal reply is useless if it isn’t filed correctly and promptly. Stick strictly to the deadline stated in the SCN. If you visualise needing more time due to real difficulties in collecting information, proactively submit a request for an extension with the publishing authority well before the deadline, clearly citing the reasons. Filing of the reply is usually done electronically through the official GST Portal. Observe the recommended procedure on the website for uploading your reply and any supplementary documents (annexures). After submitting the information effectively, ensure that you preserve the Acknowledgement Reference Number (ARN) generated by the portal. Taking a screenshot of the filing confirmation and preserving any confirmation emails received also serves as critical proof of timely compliance with show-cause notices.
Step 5: Ready for a Personal Hearing (If Requested/Offered)
In many instances, particularly those involving significant complexities or disputes, the adjudicating official will provide an opportunity for a personal hearing after receiving your written reply. Sometimes, you may need to request one specifically. A personal hearing is the chance for you to discuss your case orally, clarify any aspects in your written submission, answer questions raised by the officer, and present your evidence in person. Preparation is important. Review your written reply and supporting documents. Anticipate potential questions and think about concise and clear answers. You can be present at the hearing or arrange for a third party, such as your lawyer or tax adviser, to appear on your behalf. Make sure whoever can appear is well briefed and has all relevant available documents.
Wrapping Up
A Show Cause Notice (SCN) is an important part of the GST compliance process. Whether you are operating a small business or work within a larger organization, knowing how to deal with an SCN is important for maintaining a compliant relationship with the tax office. Your replies to SCN should be made in a timely and accurate way, not only to help reduce the likelihood of penalties, but to ensure your business stays GST compliant.
Always bear in mind that if you’re uncertain about any feature of the SCN procedure, discussing with a tax professional or a GST consultant can assist you in manoeuvring the complex rules successfully.
By remaining proactive, rectifying any mistakes, and ensuring correct documentation, you can handle the GST Show Cause Notice smoothly and prevent any longstanding legal consequences.
Related Services
