It is said that startups are the pulse of the economy because many of them require a lot of funding to turn a futuristic vision of the world into reality. Investing money in a startup is both a risky innovation and the opportunity to gain a lot of money at once. The question then arises:? What’s the best way to invest? Should you go for a Convertible Note, a SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity), or opt for direct Equity? Each structure has its nuances, benefits, and risks, and choosing the right one is critical for both investors and founders.
Here are the three investment structures that are most easily understandable; let’s break them down on how they work and compare them.
1. Convertible Notes
Convertible notes are a blend of debt financing instruments that convert to equity at some point, normally at a subsequent financing stage. It became quite appealing for early-stage startups that require a capital infusion immediately but do not wish to establish a company value yet.
Key Features
- Interest Rate: Convertible notes, being a kind of debt security, earn interest until they are converted into equity.
- Discount Rate: Usually investors get a nonstandard (for example 20-percent) rebate on the next round of funding on shares.
- Valuation Cap: In particular, this cap ensures that investors receive equity at a reasonable price so that the value will not be diluted.
- Maturity Date: If conversion doesn’t occur by a certain date, the startup must repay the principal with interest.
Advantages
- Quick and straightforward to issue.
- Defer’s valuation discussions to a future date.
- Protects investors with a valuation cap and accrued interest.
Disadvantages
- Adds debt to the company’s balance sheet.
- Complexity in structuring terms like interest and valuation caps.
- Potential conflict if repayment is required at maturity.
2. SAFE (Simple Agreement for Future Equity)
Originally, Y Combinator came up with SAFEs, which are better than convertible notes. SAFEs are different from notes in several ways: Unlike notes, SAFEs are not debt instruments—they don’t even bear interest or have a maturity date. They turn to equity at a subsequent funding round if certain conditions are met.
Key Features
- Valuation Cap and Discount: Similar to convertible notes, SAFEs may include a valuation cap and/or a discount rate for equity conversion.
- No Interest or Repayment: SAFEs eliminate debt-like features, reducing pressure on startups.
- Triggering Event: Equity conversion occurs during a qualifying funding round or liquidation event.
Advantages
- Easy to draft and execute with fewer legal complexities.
- No debt burden for the startup.
- Founder-friendly, as there’s no repayment obligation.
Disadvantages
- Lack of investor protection if the startup remains stagnant.
- Investors may also be less valued because no repayment terms are only used here.
- Conversion terms can dilute existing equity holders significantly.
3. Equity: Direct Ownership in the Company
Equity investment is a conventional method in which an investor invests capital in the company with the purchase of stocks. This approach is normally used in later rounds of financing or when both the company and the investor are prepared to discuss valuation.
Key Features
- Ownership Stake: Investors immediately acquire a percentage of the company.
- Voting Rights: Shareholders are allowed to vote, however that depends on the type of shares you buy.
- Dividends and Returns: Equity holders may receive dividends and benefit from capital appreciation.
Advantages
- Provides clarity on ownership and valuation upfront.
- Long-term alignment of interests between founders and investors.
- Attracts strategic investors who can contribute beyond capital.
Disadvantages
- Lengthy negotiation and legal processes.
- Setting a valuation early can be challenging for startups.
- Immediate dilution of founder ownership.
Key Differences between Convertible Notes, SAFEs and Equity
The following table highlights the distinctions:
| Aspect | Convertible Note | SAFE | Equity |
| Nature | Debt that converts into equity. | A contractual agreement for future equity. | Direct ownership in the company. |
| Interest Rate | Accrues interest until conversion. | No interest or repayment obligation. | Not applicable. |
| Maturity Date | Yes, repayment is required if there is no conversion. | No maturity date, reducing pressure on startups. | Not applicable. |
| Valuation | Deferred to a future funding round. | Deferred to a future funding round. | Negotiated upfront. |
| Complexity | Moderate because of interest and the rates of repayment. | Low, designed for simplicity. | High, extensive negotiations with third parties and documentation required. |
| Risk for Investors | Moderate, however, the protections like valuation caps guarantee the firms’ safety. | High because there is no repayment or interest applicable to such loans. | The performance of the startup may vary. |
Advantages and Disadvantages
- Convertible Notes have flexibility and other safeguards such as discounts and valuation caps. However, they are similar to debt in that their use can make a startup’s balance sheet look more favourable than it actually is, and repayment can lead to all sorts of problems if it becomes necessary.
- SAFEs expunge the complications associated with investments and the risks associated with debt for startups, hence making them suitable for early-stage funding. Still, they allow the borrowing firms not to have certain repayment terms, which may be off-putting to some conservative investors.
- Equity investments give ownership and a quick yardstick on value for accurate long-term interest. However, it may take a lot of time to negotiate, and founders might not agree due to the immediate dilution factor.
Choosing the Right Structure
The choice between a convertible note, a SAFE, and equity depends on the following factors:
- Stage of the Startup: SAFEs or convertible notes are popular among early-stage startups because the former does not have a set value, and the latter does not have a set valuation at the time of closing.
- Investor Preferences: Thus, risk-takers might prefer SAFEs as a security, while those seeking protection will go after convertible notes or direct equity.
- Founder Goals: For those founders looking to keep as much equity in their business as possible, SAFEs or convertible notes are a good way to avoid dilution straight away.
- Legal and Financial Implications: Equity demands more paperwork but maintains long-term balance, while SAFE and convertible notes are quicker ways with flexible levels of difficulty.
Real-World Scenarios
Discuss a start-up company that is still in the idea phase as if it is a real pre-revenue business that has an idea for a business but has not done enough to obtain the metrics needed to justify a value of several million dollars. SAFE or converting note means that the startup can get funding without worrying much about the current valuation; it is deferred to the next round, where the financials will be better.
On the other hand, a long-standing startup that is ready for Series A will perhaps select direct equity funding; It offers certainty and draws additional sophisticated investors with funds that also help in value creation.
Conclusion
Convertible notes, SAFEs and equity each have their roles to play. Far from it, as convertibles are from straight equity, they cannot be disregarded in today’s startup funding. The kind of capital that should be taken depends on the specific factors with particular regard to the growth phases of the startup and the anticipations of the investor.
SAFEs can be interesting for startups that seek quickness and which do not require complex structures. Convertible notes are intermediate to stringent protection of investors and the less rigid claims on investors with high flexibility, while equity is traditional and stable and better suited for companies that have already reached a certain maturity.
In conclusion, the one that fits the company’s vision and the investor are the most appropriate structures for investment. This means that it is only when the parties on both sides of the table possess sufficient knowledge of these instruments that they can sail through the tumultuous ocean of startup financing.
Related Services
