Home Intellectual Property Patent Infringement

Patent Infringement

A document that details an idea and gives its owner exclusive rights to stop others from developing, commercializing, or sharing it is known as an innovation-based patent. Patent infringement is the unapproved use of a patent holder's exclusive ownership. The government grants patents for a set amount of time. This proposal states that utilising a breakthrough without authorization would be deemed patent infringement, with penalties for the violator.

1,64,739 Happy Customers

Get Free Consultation

99.9% customers satisfaction guaranteed.
No Hidden charges

A Patent: What is it?

Only the patent holder or inventor is granted the right to produce, market, distribute, mortgage, and sell their creation. Patent infringement happens when someone else, not the patent holder, invents something, uses it, offers it for trade, trades it, or imports it into a country while the patent is still in effect.

"Infringement of a Patent": What does that mean?

When an invention is utilized, sold, or made available without the creator's permission, it is considered infringed upon. It amounts to using someone else's concept for financial gain or personal benefit without their permission.

Legal Framework Concerning Patent Infringement

The Indian Patent Act of 1970's sections 104 to 114 establish regulations for patent infringement in India.

Who May Report a Violation of a Patent?

A patent owner may file a claim for patent infringement if they discover that their patent has been violated. Both the patentee and the sole licensee of a patent can bring a case for patent infringement under the Patent Act, which considers any infringement evidence found after the patent has been granted.

Furthermore, anyone with the necessary licence under the particulars of the Patents Act can demand in writing as a hard copy that the patent holder make a legal action to stop further infringement. On the off chance that the patent holder fails to initiate legal proceedings within a two-month period of following receipt of the letter, the licensee may act as though they are the real owner of the patent.

Which Kinds of Patent Infringement Exist?

Direct Infringement: Producing, using, or copying a good without the approval of the patent owner is viewed as an immediate type of violation. It's possible that the individual in this situation doesn't genuinely realise that he is breaking the law. Nonetheless, it is still considered a clear violation, even though this is the case.
Indirect Infringement: It occurs when someone indirectly uses, imports, or produces the patented product. In reality, though, they are inspiring others to do so, and even that is illegal. We refer to this one as indirect infringement.

Additionally, induced infringement involves persuading or inducing someone to manufacture a patented product.

Contributory Infringement: This occurs when a person helps to commit the violation. A breach occurs when someone gives a designer a portion of a patented product to use in their creation without the patent owner's permission.
Literal Infringement: An infringement is considered literal when pronounced in all respects. Literal infringement is when you can prove the direct infringement happened without a shadow of a doubt.
Wilful violation: As the name suggests, this infringement is done on purpose. This is the kind of infringement that poses unique legal challenges. More specifically, it indicates that you know you are stealing someone else's ideas. Therefore, instead of being a case of infringement, this is something that needs to be shown.

The Doctrine of Equivalents

A legal theory known as the Doctrine of Equivalents broadens the definition of patent protection beyond the actual violation. It permits judges to determine violations by using similar patented elements. In essence, the doctrine of equivalents means that a product or method could still be deemed to violate a patent if it carries out the same function practically and in the same way to generate the same outcome. The significance of this approach is in its capacity to provide the owner of patents with sufficient defence against slight modifications or substitutions that could avoid their infringement liability.

The Burden of Proof

The burden of proof in proceedings pertaining to patent infringement first lies with the patentee or plaintiff. However, Section 104A was added by TRIPS to the Patents Act of 1970, changing it and bringing in the idea of the "reversed burden of proof." This means that if a procedure is the subject of a patent and leads to;

This is a novel product, and despite the patent holder's best efforts, It is possible that the same strategy is being employed to create a copy of the product, yet they failed to identify the method.

The burden then switches to the defendant to establish non-infringement.

What Steps Can be Taken to Stop Patent Infringement?

Here are several methods for preventing patent violation that are mentioned:

Development of Unique Products: Companies are able to find workers with the intelligence and inventiveness to create original products. To prevent employees from subsequently claiming ownership of the invention, the corporation must remember a provision in the contract declaring that the product generated is the corporation's exclusive property.
Getting the necessary patent owners' licenses: If businesses don't want to be held accountable for misusing patented material, they should get permission from the patent owner before using any material that has been registered for further purposes. Media on the internet that can be used without limitations is known as media that is royalty-free. Giving the right credit to the owner of the work will assist in shielding their exclusive rights from any patent violation.
Suit for Violation of Patent: A patentee may bring legal action under the Patents Act of 1970 if their exclusive patent rights are violated. The Limitation Act states that an action has to be filed within three years. After the patent infringement.

Usually, the plaintiff has the burden of proof to show that the defendant violated the patent, but the court may occasionally determine the burden of proof. In India, cases about patent infringement may be heard by district and higher courts.

However, if the defendant files a counterclaim seeking patent cancellation, only the High Court can hear the matter. The patent holder may bring the case to the location of his business or residence or where the cause of action initially appears. Section 48 of the Patents Act of 1970 outlines the patentees' rights. It enumerates a few actions that violate the patent holder's rights:

Using
Importing
Make Offers for Sale
Promoting the unique methodology

Remedies for Patent Infringement

Some remedies available under patent law for patent infringement include the following:

Administrative Remedy: If and when intellectual property is imported into India, the owner of the property may get in touch with the customs collector to prevent the entry of infringing goods into the market. To use this remedy, the intellectual property owner must supply the names of the exporter, the recipient, and the ship.
Civil Remedy: If the plaintiff's patent rights are violated, Section 108(1) of the Patents Act offers the plaintiff remedies. The court may award reliefs such as an injunction and, at the plaintiff's option, a profit summary or damages in any action for infringement. The three categories are as follows:
Injunction: An injunction is a civil remedy that prevents. There are two varieties:

Temporary Injunction: The offended party files a complaint, and the court quickly requests a temporary injunction. This law expected to keep the defendant from making use of new patented actions in order to obtain benefits. To look for a brief order, the owner of the patent should state that the defendant violated the patent and that the injunction is valid. Furthermore, the ensuing violation of his patent rights has caused him irrevocable bad luck.
Permanent Injunction: A permanent injunction is imposed after the court has assessed all significant proof. Assuming it is resolved that the defendant violated patent rights, the plaintiff will win, and the interval or temporary injunction will be changed over completely to a permanent one. That being said, the Interim Injunction is dissolved and is only in effect for the length of the patent if the Defendant is determined not to be at fault and proven innocent.

A Patent Infringement Lawsuit's Possible Defences

A defendant may assert a number of defences in a lawsuit alleging patent infringement to protect himself.
If it is clear that the challenged invention is not new (patent invalidation claim).
When a defendant establishes his absence of intention to deny infringement.
In the event of res judicata or estoppels.
When a plaintiff's right to file an infringement lawsuit is violated.
Where the defendant's use of the patented product is authorized, either explicitly or implicitly.
When a patent is revoked because it violates legal requirements.
The government may continue to have the sole authority to produce patented goods for the general good when it comes to pharmaceuticals.

Examining Patent Infringement

Examining a product or activity for possible patent infringement requires comparing its claims to the patent in question in a thorough manner. This is an example of how to carry out this kind of analysis:

Recognizing the Patent: Read through the patent claims to ascertain the scope of protection for the invention.
Evaluating the Accused Product or Process: To determine any possible violation, compare the product or process to the patent claims.
Taking into account the Doctrine of Equivalents: The product in question may yet violate the doctrine of equivalents. This can occur even when there isn't an apparent infringement on the claims. It happens when it carries out the same task in the same manner.

How to Prevent Violations of Patents?

Carrying Out Extensive Patent Searches: Conduct extensive patent searches before developing, manufacturing, or utilizing a novel process or product. Relevant patents can be found by using these searches.
Creating Around Patents: To prevent violating a relevant patent, modify your product or method to avoid meeting its claims.
Getting License Agreements: A patent holder must be obtained before you may use an innovation that is patented by pursuing a licensing agreement.
Remaining Up to Date: Keep yourself informed about new patents in your sector to avoid possible infringement issues.

Penalties for Violations of Patents

For patent violations in India, possible sanctions include:

Injunctions: The court gave the infringer an injunction to cease making, using, promoting, or supplying the infringing technique or product.
If there is an infringement, damages are given to the patent owner. This sum of money is known as monetary recompense.
Lost profits (earnings that the patent holder would have obtained in the absence of the infringement)
Fair royalties, or the amount the infringer would have had to pay to get a license to utilize the invention
Profits report: The court may occasionally order the party violating a patent to reimburse the owner for the money they earned from their actions.
Increased damage: A judge may fine someone up to three times their actual damages if they intentionally copy something without authorization.

What is Not Considered a Violation?

Bolar and parallel import provisions are incorporated in Section 107A of the Patents Act.

Bolar provision: It permits pharmaceutical companies to conduct research on a range of patented goods to commercialize those goods for the benefit of the public. However, the results of this research can only be considered helpful once the patented product has expired.

Provisions for parallel imports: Permits the import of the product from the party designated by the patent holder. The patent holder's rights will not be deemed violated by this importation. This meant that without the patentee's consent, anyone might import patented goods from the owner of the appropriate permit or license, which would not be regarded as an infringement.

Why Choose Kanakkupillai?

Kanakkupillai is a leading legal consulting company in India it offers a wide range of services related to Patent Registration. Protect your brand and register your Patent with ease. Secure your business identity with Kanakkupillai's Patent services. Let us handle your Patent registration while you focus on your business. We have the most reputable experts for hassle-free Patent registration. Register your Patent virtually, anytime, anywhere with Kanakkupillai. Don’t hesitate to contact us immediately.

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the relevant date from the infringement perspective? +

Although suit for infringement can only be instituted after the grant of a patent, the patentee shall have privileges as if the patent was granted on the date of publication of application, and when suing for infringement the patent owner can sue to backdate and claim damages from the date of infringement or publication of patent application whichever is later.

What is a Patent Infringement? +

A patent can be granted for a technical invention if its mechanism solves a problem in a new way. This can include methods of measuring, manufacturing, or controlling a machine, system, or product. After obtaining a patent, no third party may use that invention without the explicit consent of the patent holder. This covers tasks like continuous production, selling for sale, importation, or commercial sale within the countries where protection is sought. If these actions occur regardless, it constitutes patent infringement. Multiple individuals can be held accountable if they were involved in or encouraged the unauthorized use.

How Should I Respond to a Patent Infringement Warning? +

A patent infringement warning is a serious matter. However, upon receiving one, it's important to maintain composure. Do not act independently by signing or making payments. Also, do not contact the opposing party's lawyer. Instead, seek out a specialized patent lawyer who can guide you through the next steps. They will not only assess the legitimacy of the claim and the adequacy of the demands but may also spare you from an immensely costly legal battle in some cases.

How Do I File a Report for Patent Infringement? +

Speak with a patent attorney if you are certain that there has been a patent infringement based on your preliminary investigation. They will conduct a proper legal investigation and discuss with you a strategy for enforcing your patent rights. Typically, the first step involves issuing a warning and a cease-and-desist demand to the infringer. An out-of-court settlement is usually the initial goal, as it saves both parties a significant amount of money. Otherwise, the path leads towards a lawsuit, in which your attorney will expertly represent you. They can also assess the prospects of a lawsuit beforehand.

Can Patent Infringements be Avoided? +

There is always a certain risk of rights infringement, as competition is fierce. In India alone, over a thousand new intellectual property applications are filed annually. Keeping track of these continuously is not easy. Therefore, thorough patent research is essential—both before applying for a patent and after obtaining one. When registering, institutes check whether your invention qualifies as a novelty in the objective sense. However, they do not check whether a similar product or process is already in commercial circulation. That is your responsibility.